HO-HO-HO-Hold on here, pilgrim. SWR over PA? I have my serious doubts, sir.arank87 wrote: ↑Mon May 28, 2018 6:35 pmI just finished reading this entire thread. Yes, all of it. Here are some of my random thoughts about codger burley's:
1. CPS seems to favor SWR over PA.
2. PA gets rave reviews and then some "meh" reviews.
3. Granger is to pipe tobacco as an MRE is to food.
4. I think the term "OTC" or "Drugstore blend" is more suited to the genre than "codger burley" since there are some aromatics, etc. thrown into the discussion.
How good are the Sutliff match blends? I really want to try Walnut, Sugar Barrel, and Country Doctor but I would only want to try them if they were very close approximations of the originals.
Does anyone have any Edgeworth sealed? I have the Lane Ready Rubbed and it's my favorite tobacco so far and I would love to try the original. I have a sealed tin of Balkan Sobrannie from 2017 that I could part with. Probably a lost cause at this point but I thought I'd throw it out there.
This thread is probably one of the best pipe threads I've read yet. Thank you CPS.
There is but one name to know in all of Codger Burleydom: